Synthetic Crowds Degrade Democratic Governance
159 Coordinated Actors in 2024 Election
During the 2024 U.S. Presidential Election, ICWSM Workshop Proceedings found that 159 coordinated actors operated across multiple networks to amplify specific narratives and manufacture artificial engagement. Scientific Reports, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence, and JSTOR explain that synchronized posting and bot networks initiate this process, flooding platforms with identical messages to jumpstart viral momentum. Communications Psychology, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence, and Revista Profesional de la Información documented how automated accounts aggressively spread links from low-credibility sources early in an article's life cycle, exploiting platform algorithms that prioritize engagement and ensure users encounter similar views. These amplified signals then trigger human bandwagon effects by bombarding users with high volumes of fake content that exploit existing psychological orientations, JSTOR highlighted. Humans unwittingly reshare this bot-jumpstarted content, creating a false impression of widespread grassroots support or dissent, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence and Social Network Analysis and Mining explained. A March 2016 algorithm change on Twitter, for example, shifted timelines to prioritize popular content, increasing likes by 20% and retweets by 15% within 30 days, which caused users to conform to dominant viewpoints, according to Marcel Garz.
Astroturfing Creates 'Legitimacy Politics'
Social Network Analysis and Mining found that astroturfing, the practice of disguising sponsored messages as genuine grassroots movements, deceives the public about their own views and directly influences policymakers to favor certain political agendas under deceptive pretenses. "This enables 'legitimacy politics,' where elites manufacture the popular legitimacy of policies and bypass organic public consensus, ultimately shifting political power structures and degrading democratic decision-making," according to DiVA Portal and Social Network Analysis and Mining. The manufactured consensus compels policymakers to treat synthetic signals as reliable mandates. Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence and Revista Profesional de la Información observed that the distortion of democratic feedback is driven by both the sheer volume of coordinated accounts and their strategic placement at key information bottlenecks. Automated accounts aggressively spread links from false or low-quality sources early in an article's life cycle to jumpstart viral momentum, which humans then unwittingly reshare, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence highlighted. This strategic targeting creates content incubators on alternative platforms like Gab and Minds, where information originates before being distributed to broader audiences via networks like Telegram and the Fediverse, ICWSM Workshop Proceedings documented.
Manufactured Legitimacy Erodes Trust
Scientific Reports and Social Network Analysis and Mining concluded that while manufactured legitimacy consolidates political power by creating synthetic mandates, it consistently erodes institutional trust and fosters polarization. Social Network Analysis and Mining asserted that by disguising the real sponsors of these campaigns, astroturfing diminishes faith in online platforms and political institutions. AI-enabled tools systematically distort political information environments, which erodes public trust and fosters polarization, ultimately degrading democratic decision-making, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence warned. The accumulation of manufactured legitimacy creates a false consensus that masks societal divisions while simultaneously fragmenting shared reality to produce polarization, Communications Psychology, Scientific Reports, Louisiana State University Law Digital Commons, DiVA Portal, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence, and Social Network Analysis and Mining found. This synthetic support drowns out honest conversations and deceives the public about their own views, masking underlying societal divisions and delaying necessary policy corrections, Social Network Analysis and Mining explained. Communications Psychology and Social Network Analysis and Mining observed that voters become more vigilant and entrenched in their respective camps, deepening political hostility and conflict.
EU's AI Act of 2024
Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence documented that the distortion of public opinion and the proliferation of AI-driven disinformation prompted the adoption of the EU's AI Act in 2024, which established a risk-based framework banning unacceptable AI uses and imposing strict transparency mandates enforceable starting in 2026. Canada also proposed its Artificial Intelligence and Data Act in June 2022 to address these challenges, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence added. Scientific Reports, DiVA Portal, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence, and Social Network Analysis and Mining concluded that the deployment of coordinated fake grassroots crowds shifts political power from decentralized civic organizations to centralized data strategists, making democratic governance structurally dependent on continuous information campaigns rather than organic deliberation. Astroturfing initiatives are centrally coordinated campaigns that use human agents and AI bots to simulate genuine citizen behavior and create the illusion of widespread grassroots support, Scientific Reports and Social Network Analysis and Mining explained. Scientific Reports, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence, and Social Network Analysis and Mining described how these campaigns operate through synchronized posting, automation, and the deployment of millions of synthetic identities to flood digital platforms with biased information. This structural shift makes governance dependent on manufactured legitimacy, as false news spreads six times faster than truthful news on social media, Zeus Press Journals and Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence found. Communications Psychology, Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence, and Social Network Analysis and Mining observed that digital platforms and algorithms amplify this dependency by creating echo chambers and prioritizing emotionally charged content, accelerating political polarization and eroding public trust.
Fabricated Mandates Undermine Consensus
The widespread deployment of coordinated fake grassroots crowds fundamentally undermines the principle of public consensus as the basis for political legitimacy; this shift means policymakers risk responding to fabricated mandates rather than genuine constituent needs, leading to policies that may not reflect the true will or best interests of the electorate. Democratic governance becomes structurally reliant on continuous, often deceptive, information campaigns, diminishing the role of organic civic engagement and empowering centralized data strategists and political actors who can effectively deploy these tools.
Comments ()